top of page

Beyond the AAA Bond Rating: What Pittsford's Financial History Can Tell Us.

Nov 3
6 min read

Seven charts, sixteen years of financial data, and a few questions worth asking. (Turn on your bankers lamp and put on your nerdiest glasses...let's get into it...).


Pittsford is proud of its AAA bond rating. A strong rating tells us something important: lenders have confidence in the Town's ability to repay its debts. But I've been wondering about a different question: Does being creditworthy necessarily mean we're financially sustainable over the long term?


With the Town Board considering the proposed 2027 budget, I decided to do some homework. I took historical financial information from Pittsford's audited reports and worked through the Strong Towns Finance Decoder, which turns complex municipal financial data into seven visual indicators. Rather than looking only at next year's proposed spending, it helps us ask where we've been, what we own, what we owe, and what our choices may mean for the next generation.


How to read these charts: Each graph is a starting point, not a final verdict. The measures use different definitions of financial resources, obligations, and assets. A dramatic change can reflect an accounting rule or a one-time capital project as well as a change in financial policy.


1. Net Financial Position

In the first part of the series, Pittsford reported a positive net financial position. That changed sharply beginning in the mid-2010s. The line reached its lowest point around 2020 and has recovered considerably through 2025, though it remains negative.

This metric subtracts liabilities from financial assets—resources such as cash and receivables. It does not count a road or community building as money available to pay an obligation.


Before assuming the Town simply spent beyond its means, we need to understand what changed on paper. In 2015, GASB 68 changed the recognition of pension liabilities. In 2017, Pittsford adopted GASB 75 early, bringing retiree healthcare obligations more prominently into its reported financial position. That adoption included a roughly $12.9 million downward restatement of previously reported net position.


Those obligations matter. But reporting them differently isn't the same thing as suddenly spending that amount of cash.


Question: Of the improvement since 2020, how much reflects stronger financial resources, changes in long-term benefit obligations, debt repayment, or other factors?





2. Financial Assets to Total Liabilities

The ratio fell from substantially above 100% in the early years to well below 100%, and has since improved to roughly 80% in 2025. A ratio below 100% means the measure of financial assets in this framework is less than reported liabilities. It does not mean those liabilities are all payable today, or that the Town is about to run out of cash.

It does prompt questions about flexibility: how much room do we have to handle surprises while still meeting commitments made in previous years?


Question: What does the Town's current liquidity, reserve policy, and long-term liability forecast tell us beyond this one ratio?



3. Total Assets to Total Liabilities

Here we add physical capital assets—facilities, infrastructure, equipment, and similar property—to the picture. On this measure, Pittsford's reported assets have consistently exceeded liabilities, but the ratio fell sharply in the mid-2010s before recovering.

That distinction matters. A building is a valuable public asset, but it cannot readily be used to meet payroll or make a bond payment. Meanwhile, buildings, roads, and drainage systems require continued investment. So an asset-rich town can still face real questions about the cash and revenue needed to maintain its assets.


Question: What share of our asset value represents infrastructure that will require major rehabilitation or replacement over the next decade?




4. Net Debt to Total Revenues

This chart increases dramatically from 2016 to 2020, then declines through 2025. Here the decoder's term net debt is broader than just outstanding municipal bonds: the calculation is related to liabilities net of financial assets. Actual borrowing still matters. In 2017, Pittsford issued approximately $8.8 million in bonds for the Spiegel Community Center project. A major renovation may be an appropriate investment in a long-lived public facility. But we should examine the full cost, expected benefits, and future maintenance—not only the Town's capacity to borrow. The accounting changes described earlier also affect how to interpret this line. We shouldn't equate every increase in this chart with new bonds.


Question: How does planned borrowing fit into the full schedule of principal, interest, maintenance, and replacement costs?




5. Interest to Total Revenues

The share of annual revenue devoted to interest has generally declined over the period shown, including a pronounced decline since 2018. That may provide more room in annual budgets for other priorities. But the chart does not show all debt service. Principal repayments matter, too, and both compete with annual operating and capital needs.


Question: What percentage of recurring revenue is committed to principal and interest over the next five to ten years?



6. Net Book Value to Cost of Tangible Capital Assets

This may be the chart that interests me most. The ratio improved through 2018, reaching around 53%, before declining to roughly 42% in 2025. Net book value reflects original asset costs minus accumulated depreciation. A new or substantially renovated building can raise the ratio. Pittsford's substantial improvements to the Spiegel Community Center help explain the late-2010s increase, though we'd need the full capital-asset schedules to apportion the change across projects.


A declining ratio does not prove that the Town is failing to maintain its assets. Depreciation is an accounting measure, not a physical condition assessment. Still, the line asks us to look beyond ribbon cuttings and construction costs. Do we know the condition and expected replacement dates of our roads, sidewalks, stormwater systems, facilities, and equipment? Are we setting aside enough to care for what we already have?


Question: How do proposed 2027 maintenance and capital appropriations compare with the Town's documented needs and replacement schedule?




7. Government Transfers to Total Revenues

This series is uneven, with notable peaks in individual years, especially 2022, followed by a lower share in 2025. It brings to mind our conversations with state representatives about grants. Outside funding can help with sidewalks, playgrounds, transportation connections, and other projects that residents value.


But one-time money is different from recurring support. A grant can help us build something without paying to maintain it for decades. And this chart groups government transfers; it should not be read as a count of competitive grants the Town applied for or received. That makes me interested in capital partnerships, too—with our school district, neighboring municipalities, universities, transit partners, and infrastructure agencies—when coordinated investment could avoid duplicate work or spread real costs fairly.


Question: Which outside-funded investments create ongoing Town obligations, and how are those future costs accounted for?



And what about keeping taxes flat?

Pittsford has placed considerable emphasis on maintaining a flat Town property-tax rate. Keeping taxes affordable matters, especially for residents on fixed incomes. But a flat rate is not necessarily a flat total tax levy, and neither tells us by itself whether every necessary expense has been funded. A balanced budget establishes that proposed appropriations are covered by estimated revenue and other available resources. It does not independently establish that we have identified and funded every reasonable maintenance, replacement, and capital need.


That isn't an accusation that Pittsford has neglected those responsibilities. It's a reason to ask how priorities were set. What work is funded in the 2027 proposal, what has been deferred, and what would it cost to address the remaining needs? I'd also like to understand the Town's longer-term capital plan. What are we committed to maintaining? When is replacement more economical than another repair? And are there partnerships or coordinated projects that would let us use public dollars more effectively?


This is about asking better questions


The Finance Decoder is not a report card on Pittsford's financial management. It is not a substitute for audited statements, our Finance Director's professional judgment, infrastructure condition assessments, or the Town Board's annual budget process.

It is a way to make financial information more accessible, so residents and Board members can ask thoughtful questions about our choices. Our AAA bond rating tells us something important about our ability to repay financial obligations. These charts encourage us to ask another question: Are we investing what is necessary to sustain our community over time?


I've shared the charts with my Town Board colleagues and welcomed Finance Director Brian Luke's perspective. I'm also interested in hearing what neighbors see in the data.

What surprises you? What questions would you ask? What might we be missing? As I say on campus, I welcome all the brains I can borrow. Because the goal isn't just to understand how much Pittsford spends. It's to understand what we're building, what we're maintaining, and what we're leaving for the next generation.


About the data

These graphics were created using the Strong Towns Finance Decoder framework and historical financial figures compiled from Town of Pittsford financial reporting. They display 2010–2025, including 2018. Historical comparisons are affected by changes in accounting standards, particularly GASB 68 and GASB 75. Interpretations here are exploratory and are not an independent audit or a formal evaluation of the Supervisor's proposed 2027 budget.


Editorial note: The Strong Towns slide template sometimes says “city.” The municipality represented here is the Town of Pittsford.


Sources and further reading

 
 
 

Comments


Pittsford, NY 14534

‪(585) 348-8278

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Town and Gown Substack
  • LinkedIn

 

© 2026 by ChaRon Sattler-Leblanc. Powered and secured by Wix 

 

bottom of page